TY - CHAP
T1 - A critical examination of Chinese influences on Quesnay
AU - van den Berg, Richard
PY - 2022
Y1 - 2022
N2 - For one century a variety of authors has defended the thesis that Francois Quesnay (1694-1774), one of the most prominent European economic theorists of the 18th century, was fundamentally influenced by Chinese practices and social philosophy. This chapter takes a critical look at such claims. It finds that the textual evidence for this, even in Quesnay's Despotisme de la Chine of 1767, is limited. It concludes that some claims, for example, the supposed Chinese origin of the Tableaux economiques, can simply be discounted. If there was some influence of sources from or about China on other parts of Quesnay's thought, for example on his theory of 'legitimate despotism', then this influence was likely of a confirmative (i.e., fitting with opinions that he also reached in different ways) and a transformative (i.e. shaped by the context of his own time and place) nature.
AB - For one century a variety of authors has defended the thesis that Francois Quesnay (1694-1774), one of the most prominent European economic theorists of the 18th century, was fundamentally influenced by Chinese practices and social philosophy. This chapter takes a critical look at such claims. It finds that the textual evidence for this, even in Quesnay's Despotisme de la Chine of 1767, is limited. It concludes that some claims, for example, the supposed Chinese origin of the Tableaux economiques, can simply be discounted. If there was some influence of sources from or about China on other parts of Quesnay's thought, for example on his theory of 'legitimate despotism', then this influence was likely of a confirmative (i.e., fitting with opinions that he also reached in different ways) and a transformative (i.e. shaped by the context of his own time and place) nature.
U2 - 10.4324/9780367434496-24
DO - 10.4324/9780367434496-24
M3 - Chapter
SN - 9780367434489
T3 - Routledge Studies in the History of Economics
SP - 215
EP - 229
BT - European and Chinese Histories of Economic Thought. Theories and Images of Good Governance
A2 - Amelung, Iwo
A2 - Schefold, Bertram
PB - Routledge
CY - London and New York
ER -