Abstract
Interprofessional collaboration (IPC) is believed to be a key ingredient in delivering
high quality patient care and addressing failings within the NHS. The means to
improving interprofessional collaboration within healthcare teams is unquestionably
through interprofessional education (IPE). This is a global concern, and as such it is
important to drive the agenda forward within my own profession of diagnostic
radiography.
Consequently, the aim of this research study is to explore diagnostic radiography
students' perception of interprofessional collaboration and the factors that influence it.
The ultimate purpose being to utilise the findings of this study to better prepare
diagnostic radiography students for collaboration through improvements in the
interprofessional education curriculum.
A phenomenological approach was used, and semi-structured interviews were carried
out using carefully constructed vignettes as prompts. The vignettes reflected
interprofessional collaborative teamwork and included ineffective collaboration to
allow for comment on the factors perceived to influence it. A sample of twelve third
year diagnostic radiography students from a London University participated in the
study.
The data was analysed using thematic analysis as specified by Colaizzi (1978). The
overarching themes that emerged were:
ÔØû Personal capabilities
ÔØû Skills Mix
ÔØû Interpersonal relationships
ÔØû Radiography culture
ÔØû Organisation/environment
With a central theme of role-taking
The study concluded that diagnostic radiography students appear ill-equipped for
interprofessional collaborative teamwork. The analysis shows that the students are
6
lacking in leadership capabilities needed to navigate the persuasive hidden curriculum
and resist normalisation into the culture of compliance of the team or organisation.
Furthermore, the results oppose findings on professional identity, which is considered
to cause turf protectionism and tribalism hindering collaboration. Instead this study
proposes that a strong professional identity breeds confidence and resilience aiding
collaboration. It is not just IPE that influences collaboration however. Organisational
pressures such as funding, time frames and workload appear complicit in fuelling a
culture of compliance.
A representation of a model of profession social closure is presented, demonstrating
similarities and differences from Witz's (1992) model, based on the perceptions of a
small group of diagnostic radiography students. This small-scale study rejects the
suggestion that professions work as a single entity to demarcate with domination and
subordination. There were no perceived exclusion strategies between the subordinate
professions. Instead, it suggests that exclusion occurs between in and out groups with
normalisation to the group. Inclusionary strategies through advanced expert
knowledge appears to be successful with improved collaboration between dominant
and subordinate professions.
Enhancing interprofessional collaboration is recommended through application of the
three successive levels of transformative learning within the diagnostic radiography
curriculum. This should include strengthening professional identity, continued
interprofessional socialisation and the introduction of leadership skills alongside
reflective practice, to enable students to negotiate the hidden curriculum.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Qualification | Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Supervisors/Advisors |
|
| Publication status | Accepted/In press - Nov 2022 |
Bibliographical note
Physical Location: Online Only.Keywords
- Education
PhD type
- Standard route